W. E. Arthur et al. to Thomas E. Bramlette

KYR-0001-004-2452.xml

Metadata
Citation
Download

Accession Number

KYR-0001-004-2452

Document Genre

Petition

Repository

Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives

Collection

Office of the Governor, Thomas E. Bramlette: Governor's official correspondence file, petitions for pardons, remissions, and respites 1863-1867

Item Location

BR15-404 to BR15-405

Place of Creation

Covington, Kenton County, Kentucky

Date of Creation

16 October 1865

Dates Mentioned

1865-10-16

1865-09

1865-10-18

W. E. Arthur et al. to Thomas E. Bramlette, 16 October 1865, Office of the Governor, Thomas E. Bramlette: Governor's official correspondence file, petitions for pardons, remissions, and respites 1863-1867, BR15-404 to BR15-405, Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives, Frankfort, KY. Accessed via the Civil War Governors of Kentucky Digital Documentary Edition, discovery.civilwargovernors.org/document/KYR-0001-004-2452, (accessed April 22, 2025).

Download XML

Covington, Ky. Oct 16^th 1865
To the Hon. Thomas E. Bramlette
Governor of the Com'th of Kentucky --

The Undersigned, Citizens of Covington, respectfully represent that in the Circuit Court for the County of Kenton, held in this City, at the September Term thereof 1865, Thomas Estep was tried, convicted and fined $50, on an Indictment for, with a pistol, shooting at James Westowrth with the intent to Kill or wound him. These are substantially the material facts proven in the trial: -- Wentworth without provocation struck Frank Estep, brother of Thomas, a violent blow in the face & eye, causing Frank to reel and fall, whereupon Thomas instantly drew and fired, two shots -- one of these went in the ground, the other in the air, and once the pistol missed fire, Wentworth was not five feet from him when the firing occurred. One witness said the pistol was in the direction of Wentworth -- two witnesses said it was not pointed at
Wentworth, and one that Thomas Estep did not shoot at Wentworth, but shot in the air, and one that he knocked the pistol up and the charge went in the air.

The jury were of the opinion that the evidence authorized a conviction and so found. It was contended for Estep, that, for the sole purpose of protecting his brother from further injury, he fired in the air to intimidate Wentworth, and did not fire at him. This was Thomas Estep solemn assurance to his Counsel and an Estep is a truthful man. In the Mayors Court of this City Thomas Estep was fined $50 for carrying that pistol on that occasion, and he has paid that fine.

These fines are a grievous burden to him. Your Excellency will learn from this petition that they grew out of an unforeseen Casualty with which Thomas Estep was complicated solely by an involuntary impulse and to save his brother from grievous bodily harm. He is advised that Executive clemency may relieve him of $35 of the fine
in the Circuit Court, exclusive of fees and costs. To that end he respectfully invokes your clemency, and we unite with him in this his peititon, and warmly Commend him to Executive favor as a person worthy of the clemency sought.

Names

W E Arthur
Geo T. Perkins
A. C. Ellis
W. H. Tebbs
J. W. Menzies
Levi F. Daugherty
H S Halley
H C. Timberlake
Ben Moore
David DeGarno
Joel H Meglasson
Ben. L. Meglasson
Tho. L. Arnold
Sam^l H Stout
R Simmons
F. Smith
W. Smith
W A, Kennedy
S C Perrin

M. J. Dudley
R. K. Irwin
B Young
Charles. W. Clayton
Jno E Hamilton
J. E Clendening
David M^cKay
Jos Havlin
J H Easton
John B. Casey & Son
John Clayton
J. O'Hara Jr
F B Rust
R. Richardson
M. D. Moore
John Todd
Geo Magee
John. C. Taylor
Denis P. Noonan
Chas G Wallace

Kenton Cir Court
vs
Thomas Estep et, al,
To } Petition
The Governer

$50,
18 Oct /65
Remit

Early Access is a work in progress. Help us improve our edition by suggesting a correction for this document.

Suggest a correction